Tool marks and physical matching
A tool mark is any mark a tool leaves on another surface.
| Type | How it's made | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Impression | Tool pressed into a softer surface | Hammer or crowbar mark on a door frame |
| Striated | Tool slides across a surface, leaving fine parallel lines | Screwdriver prying a window |
| Cutting | Sharp edges cut through material | Bolt cutters on a padlock |
At the scene, photograph the mark with oblique lighting, then collect the whole object if possible. If not, make a cast with silicone rubber. Never try the suspect tool in the mark: it could change the mark and destroy the evidence.
In the laboratory, the examiner makes test marks with the suspect tool and compares them with the scene mark under a comparison microscope, looking at class features first (size, shape) and then fine striations caused by manufacturing and wear. 3D surface scanning and SEM are also used.
Typical conclusions are: the tool made the mark (identification), could have made it, did not make it (elimination), or the comparison is inconclusive.
Physical matching (fracture matching) shows that broken pieces were once one object: torn paper, broken glass, cut tape or rope. A perfect fit of irregular edges is among the strongest forms of physical evidence.
Building materials, metals and alloys
Cement, concrete, plaster, bricks and tiles can transfer to shoes, tools and vehicles in burglaries and blasts. Metals and alloys turn up as tools, weapons, wires, vehicle parts and bullets.
| Material | Typical examinations |
|---|---|
| Cement, concrete, plaster | Microscopy, XRD (minerals), XRF (elements), FTIR |
| Metals (iron, steel, copper, aluminium, lead) | Hardness tests, metallography (grain structure under a microscope), SEM |
| Alloys (brass = copper + zinc; bronze = copper + tin; stainless steel = iron + chromium + nickel) | Elemental composition by XRF, ICP-MS, SEM-EDS |
Forensic metallurgy also investigates why things fail: fatigue cracks, corrosion, poor heat treatment or tampering in collapsed structures and broken machinery.
Pause and answer
- Why should a suspect screwdriver never be tried in the tool mark at the scene?
- What does brass contain?
